Emily Wilson’s ‘Odyssey’ became a cultural flashpoint. Now, she’s retranslating the whole thing
PUBLISHED Aug 29, 2026, 8:34 AM ET
Read, Watch or Listen
Classicist Emily Wilson is creating a new translation of Homer's 'Odyssey', eight years after her landmark 2017 version sold over a million copies. Wilson, the first woman to translate the epic into English, announced she is 'about halfway through' a 'complete retranslation' to correct flaws such as overusing the word 'slave'. The announcement follows a public dispute with filmmaker Christopher Nolan, whose blockbuster adaptation cited Wilson's opening line as inspiration. Wilson wrote a scathing London Review of Books review, calling Nolan's script 'abysmal'. Author Joyce Carol Oates criticized Wilson's 'haughty superiority' and rhetoric, comparing it to 'MAGA folks'. Wilson has expressed regret over framing her critique of the film's use of actors of color but stood by her assessment. The retranslation project is considered a highly unusual move for a translator. The new edition will feature more extensive end notes and is a few years from completion.
By Michael Grant | JQJO News
Timeline of Events
- 2017 — Wilson's landmark 'Odyssey' translation is published and becomes a bestseller.
- 2019 — Wilson awarded MacArthur 'genius' fellowship for her scholarly work.
- 2023 — Wilson publishes her translation of Homer's 'Iliad'.
- On November 1 2025 Nolan cites Wilson's opening line as inspiration for film.
- On July 27 2026 Wilson publishes scathing review of Nolan's film in LRB.
- On July 29 2026 Joyce Carol Oates criticizes Wilson's 'haughty' review tone.
- On August 27 2026 Wilson announces to AP she is retranslating 'Odyssey' from scratch.
- On August 29 2026 Reporting confirms Wilson is 'halfway through' the new translation.
- On August 29 2026 Debate continues over Wilson's review and retranslation decision.
- 2029 — Wilson's new 'Odyssey' translation is expected to be published.
News Intelligence
- Immediate US impact: Academic and film circles are debating artistic interpretation and criticism.
- Possible long-term US impact: This dispute may shape future adaptations of classical works.
- Most affected groups: Classicists, film scholars, fans of Nolan, and general readers.
- Reader priority: Distinguish between translation critique and film criticism's distinct merits.
- Articles Published:
- 18
- Right Leaning:
- 0
- Left Leaning:
- 5
- Neutral:
- 13
- Distribution:
- Left 28%, Center 72%, Right 0%
Left: Emphasizes Wilson's scholarly authority and dismisses Oates' criticism. Center: Focuses on factual reporting of the dispute and retranslation announcement. Right: Insufficient evidence from collected coverage to determine right-leaning framing.
AP interview with Emily Wilson announcing her complete retranslation of 'Odyssey'. https://apnews.com/article/emily-wilson-odyssey-nolan-translation-82e59f716a63c4eaef35e782109e588b
Coverage of Story:
From Left
Unphased by discourse, Emily Wilson is translating The Odyssey, again
AV Club The Guardian Los Angeles Times The Boston Globe The Daily BeastFrom Center
Emily Wilson’s ‘Odyssey’ became a cultural flashpoint. Now, she’s retranslating the whole thing
Associated Press The New York Times The Spokesman-Review The Week The Hindu eKathimerini.com TribLIVE.com thecanadianpressnews.ca NBC10 Philadelphia Geo.tv Outlook India IMDb IMDbFrom Right
No right-leaning sources found for this story.
Comments