EA Sports College Football 26's ratings for Ohio State players have been criticized by Eleven Warriors. Linebacker Payton Pierce (74), safety Jaylen McClain (77), and offensive linemen Luke Montgomery (78) and Austin Siereveld (78) are considered undervalued, despite their potential and contributions. Defensive tackle Kayden McDonald (80), while not poorly rated, is seen as capable of exceeding his rating. These players' performances and coaches' comments suggest their in-game ratings don't reflect their true abilities.

Prepared by Emily Rhodes and reviewed by editorial team.