CRIME & LAW

Multistate Settlement Requires Menards Reform and Payments

PUBLISHED Dec 17, 2025, 4:27 PM ET

Read, Watch or Listen

Multistate Settlement Requires Menards Reform and Payments

Media Bias Meter

Sources: 11

Center 100%

Sources: 11

Madison, Wis. Officials announced Wednesday that Menards agreed to a $4.25 million multistate settlement resolving allegations that its '11% rebate' advertising misled customers and that the chain engaged in price gouging during the COVID-19 pandemic. The settlement, co-led by Wisconsin, Minnesota, Illinois and Iowa, requires clearer disclosures about rebate terms, quicker online rebate tracking, extended claim periods, and cessation of certain advertising practices. Menards will pay designated shares to participating states — Wisconsin receiving over $750,000 and Iowa approximately $446,832 — and implement operational changes to improve consumer transparency. State oversight continues. Based on 11 articles reviewed and supporting research.

By Sidra | JQJO News

Timeline of Events

2020: Consumers and some state officials raised complaints about Menards' 11% rebate advertising and pandemic pricing.
2020–2021: A coalition of state attorneys general, co-led by Minnesota, Wisconsin, Illinois and Iowa, opened coordinated investigations.
Investigations found advertising that implied point-of-purchase discounts and identified water-price increases at two Wisconsin stores during the pandemic.
States negotiated settlement terms requiring clearer disclosures, operational changes, and monetary payments to participating states.
Officials announced a $4.25 million multistate settlement and specified state shares and compliance requirements.

Media Bias

Articles Published:: 11
Right Leaning:: 0
Left Leaning:: 0
Neutral:: 11
Distribution:: Left 0%, Center 100%, Right 0%

Who Benefited

Consumers and state enforcement agencies benefited from clearer rebate disclosures, mandated operational changes, and monetary settlements aimed at restitution and preventing future deceptive practices.

Who Impacted

Some Menards customers suffered financial harm from misleading rebate advertising and pandemic-era price increases; Menards incurred reputational damage and financial penalties.