After 20 years administering the AP Top 25 college football poll, the author now joins the voting panel. The decision wasn't easy, as they previously preferred objectivity. Their voting strategy involved using multiple computer ranking systems to create a composite, considering factors like returning starters and quarterback experience. While relying on data, the author acknowledges subjective elements and 'vibes' influenced their choices, particularly regarding quarterback uncertainty and team potential. The author anticipates criticism but commits to serious consideration in their voting.

Prepared by Emily Rhodes and reviewed by editorial team.